看來Jon不是艾德的私生子這一點得到大家的共識,我不是腦殘粉所以都是被劇情推著走的從來沒有去想過背後的可能。但是聽了導遊的解說之後覺得好有道理,推理來自於全篇從未提到艾德是親生爸爸,只有臨分別前一句you have my blood。 1.看前面的答案Jon是艾德妹妹和雷加的孩子的呼聲最高,也是最有道理的。因為三條龍需要人駕馭,如果他有龍族的血緣,可能其中一個就是去找Jon了。 2.他可能是班揚叔叔的孩子。推理來自於他要加入nights watch的時候,叔叔勸他,you father no son的時候說了一句大概是體驗過的人才懂得,所以可能叔叔本身有孩子的而且可能就是Jon.現在叔叔還沒找到呢,可能也是一條線索。 3.艾瑪,第三種都不記得了。等我想起來再寫(在刷原著)
哈哈,題主還沒看第五季呀。告訴你哦,這季只能用「我的朋友都死了」(All My Friends Are Dead)這個書名來形容本季編劇與導演的喪心病狂。也不知道是製作經費吃緊,還是演員工會要求漲工資,或者單純是編劇失戀報復社會;總之,以本季大刀砍人頭的進度,待到完片,維斯特洛大陸上唯一能動的大概就是異鬼了吧。而作為第五季獻上的壓軸祭品,雪諾大人的是死是活,除了馬胖沒人說得算。
It"s not that Jon has to survive to the end and be the "hero who saves the world"; it"s just that a death at this stage, before he learns the truth of his parentage and immediately after foreshadowing a direct confrontation (or connection) with the Night"s King (in the show - that scene doesn"t exist in the books, but the books are much heavier on dropping hints about his birth and importance) makes no sense at all.
Or rather, it makes no sense at all unless it"s merely intended to shock and surprise and make people cry, which would be lazy writing and would almost reduce the entire saga to something of a shaggy dog story (a tale full of extensive narrative information which ultimately means nothing and goes nowhere, finishing in anticlimax). To spend so much time leaving clues and hints about Jon"s origins and possible importance to the story, only to randomly and suddenly remove him from the plot at a moment entirely lacking in narrative importance and before any of these questions are answered, would be very shaggy dog writing. It would be like having Daenerys die by falling from her dragon, or Tyrion choke on a bacon sandwich after drinking too much wine, or Bran freeze to death in the forest after suddenly realising that he has been imagining the whole thing with the three-eyed raven. We know that GRRM likes to toy with the idea of "heroism" and the traditional fantasy arc, but there comes a point where you need an arc to hold the story together. Yes, real life is meaningless and cruel, people do "just die" at inconvenient moments and without the world waiting for them to complete their "arc" or "purpose"; but we don"t read books to be reminded that life is meaningless and cruel.
So - not because he has to be "Azor Ahai" and "save the world", and not because we love him, but just because his death makes no sense from a narrative perspective - I"m willing to give GRRM the benefit of the doubt, assume he"s not trolling, and say that Jon will be back (somehow, in some form, in some way).
Addendum: there is a narrative idea which could make sense, and result in Jon never returning; if his blood, being King"s blood, performs some important purpose - e.g. seeping into the Wall and awakening a dragon, or bringing the Wall down so that the White Walkers can pass, or resurrecting Stannis (!); in other words, if his death actually serves a narrative purpose other than simple shock value; but I still don"t like it, and I still think it would represent shaggy dog writing. I"ll be disappointed if it turns out that Jon"s only purpose in the story was bleeding to death.
Jon Snow will die. However there are numerous clues in the books that hinted at how Jon Snow will come back that are not in the show:
1. Jon Snow"s death will release him from his oath to the Night"s Watch.
2. Jon Snow wargs into Ghost prior to his death.
Unlike the show, Jon has shown the ability to warg. Also, in the books his last words was "Ghost." as opposed to "Olly." It is also hinted in the prologue of ADwD that skinchangers can live in the animals they warg into prior to their deaths, even though their bodies are dead. This is a mean to preserve Jon"s mind / soul. However, the longer one stays in an animal, he / she will slowly lose their human self and fully become the animal. That would mean that Jon still needs his body.
But how will the show be doing it since Jon has never shown to have the ability to warg? While GRRM has confirmed that ALL the Stark kids can warg, the show has never explored that. It could be that in the show universe, only those with the blood of the First Man AND who has experienced physical trauma will be able to warg, i.e. Bran becoming a cripple, Bloodraven losing his eye (and maybe Arya being blinded). Jon"s stabbing could awaken his warging ability.
There is a picture that was circulating in the internet prior to the airing of S5E10. It was supposedly a leaked of the FTW scene. I will include it in the comments, in case it is real and too spoilery. However, since it didn"t appear in the show, it could have been photoshopped, or that the show had withheld it for S6.
3. Jon Snow will be resurrected by Melisandre.
Remember the Brotherhood without Banners in Season 3, Thoros of Myr (a red priest) has shown the ability to resurrect the dead. He brought Beric Dondarrion back to life 6 times. It is no coincidence that Melisandre had come back to the Wall just as FTW scene was going to happen. This is a big hint.
But how will this be accomplished in the show, I have no idea. I have always believed that Melisandre will sacrifice Shireen in order to resurrect Jon (in the books, Stannis left Melisandre, Queen Selyse, and Shireen at the Wall). But now that Shireen was already sacrificed to bring good weather, maybe there would still be leftover power to bring back Jon?
There is also a question of whether Melisandre, albeit a red priestess, has the ability of ressurection. Perhaps followers of R"hllor may differ in their abilities. We have never seen Melisandre done such magic in the books or show, but it could be that such a precedence would give away too much, or that nobody important has died for her to use that magic.
(It wouldn"t surprise me if Bran / Bloodraven will end up being the one to bring Jon back. However seeing that Bran is absent in S5, the show might not have enough time to set this up for Jon"s revival.)
4. Lastly, this foreshadowing:
1.突破誓言 2.之前大家疑問狼去哪了。這裡說是在snow死之前進入異鬼區了 3.Melisandre 會救(個人比較偏向於這) 4.Sam:he always comes back
1. Maester Aemon tells Jon Snow 「Kill the boy…and let the man be born」!! So the boy is dead now and Jon Snow will return as a man, as a much stronger character.
2. Now this one』s a spoiler even if you watched all episodes. Kit Harrington is getting a pay raise (http://www.hollywoodreporter.com...) for further seasons. So yeah, he is dead and will get more salary for the seasons he will not be a part of. Ha!
下一季snow演員漲工資了
3. He』s Going To Be A Dragon Rider
Jon Snow can』t die — I mean, he』s obviously destined to be one of the three dragon riders, right? The dragon riders theory is perhaps the most popular theory in the entire ASOIAF fandom (besides the all-but-proven R + L = J theory, of course): Based off of Daenerys』 multiple visions in the trippy House of the Undying, many believe that the series will end with Dany riding off on Drogon, flanked by two as-of-yet-undecided riders on Viserion and Rhaegal.
Of course, it would make sense if the extra two dragon riders were Targaryens — and as things stand now, Jon and Tyrion seem the most likely candidates. After all, they were both name-checked as major players by Martin, and they』re both rumored to have secret Targaryen parents (for Tyrion, some believe that Aerys Targaryen had a likely non-consensual relationship with Joanna Lannister — which would certainly help explain why Tywin always hated him so gosh-darn much, and for Jon, see the aforementioned R + L = J theory).
好像國外已經確認snow是塔格利安家族的人,並認為他會是龍騎士。
of course, actually the son of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark. Though the majority of the obsessed agree on this point, it hasn"t come out in the open yet. It wouldn"t make much sense to reveal this only after his death, and it opens up all sorts of plot avenues if he is alive. He is on the short list of viable heirs to the throne, and a strong contender to be one of the three heads of the dragon, and/or the prince that was promised.
這裡也確認了snow的身世
英文的有點亂,我總結幾點,分析我就不翻譯了。 1.國外已經確認snow是塔格利安家族的人,並認為他會是龍騎士。他會是王座的競爭者,和題目一樣,龍母為火,他為冰,冰與火之歌。 2.他的血是 King"s blood,塗在長城上會喚醒黑龍或者使長城崩塌,異鬼入侵,復活 Stannis 3.之前大家疑問狼去哪了。這裡說是在snow死之前進入異鬼區了 4.Melisandre 會救(個人比較偏向於這) 5.Sam:he always comes back 6.史塔克家族的人可以進入狼的身體。 7. 花了這麼長時間鋪墊,剛知道身世就死了,不合常理,就像小惡魔喝酒被噎死一樣。 8.下一季snow演員漲工資了