Dash的開發者 Bogdan Popescu發布了新的博文 Dash and Apple: My Side of the Story,大概說明了來龍去脈。目前看來, 應該不是Dash這款應用有Review Manipulation的行為, 而是Bogdan的一個親戚的應用。3-4年前,Bogdan用他的信用卡幫這個親戚開了Apple』s Developer Program Membership, 還給了她自己不再用的測試設備,從此以後他的賬戶和那個親戚的賬戶就被link在一起了。蘋果周五提出如果Bodgan發布博文承認錯誤可以恢復他的賬戶,被拒絕。今晚,蘋果會通過一個發言人來責備 Bogdan「在公眾場合非難(Manipulating) Apple Store」。文章最後還附了一段他和蘋果溝通時的通話錄音。---從Twitter上來看,Bogdan在考慮把iOS版的Dash開源出來。
Apple 高官 Phill Schiller 向 Matthew Eis 證實 Dash 研發者帳號停權的原因:
Hi Matthew,
Thanks for your email about this app.
I did look into this situation when I read about it today. I am told this app was removed due to repeated fraudulent activity.
We often terminate developer accounts for ratings and review fraud, including actions designed to hurt other developers. This is a responsibility that we take very seriously, on behalf of all of our customers and developers.
I hope that you understand the importance of protecting the App Store from repeated fraudulent activity.
I think the thing we"re concerned about is that we don"t believe there"s a mistake here, right? We don"t think we made a mistake. We believe that the two accounts are linked and one of the accounts defiantly had fraudulent activities. We wanna make sure that"s CLEAR.
因為作者存在兩個賬號共用一張信用卡還有測試設備,這兩個賬號是關聯的而且另一個賬號有欺詐行為。
但是作者在博客里寫到:
3-4 years ago I helped a relative get started by paying for her Apple』s Developer Program Membership using my credit card. I also handed her test hardware that I no longer needed. From then on those accounts were linked in the eyes of Apple. Once that account was involved with review manipulation, my account was closed.
作者認為他沒有做錯,他不應該對另一個賬號的欺詐行為負責,那個賬號不是他的。然後在電話里還說想不想讓這次談話公開。Apple 說公開對他們來說完全沒有問題,因為這兩個賬號確實是關聯了,還有多個因素來證明確實違反了使用條款。Apple 給出的方案是,想讓作者發文說明這一點:作者知道兩個賬號是關聯的,並且另一個賬號存在欺詐行為,Apple 沒有做錯。然後 Apple 來幫作者解封賬號,這對作者和 Apple 都 Fair Enough。從作者的更新來看,他寫了這篇文章,然後發給了 Apple ,但是卻沒有再收到回復。文章內容是:
Apple contacted me and told me that my account will be reactivated.
My account wasn"t involved with ratings or review fraud, but instead it was closed because a few years ago I helped a fellow developer get started by paying for the Apple Developer Program Membership using my credit card. I also handed test hardware that I no longer needed, which looked to Apple like I was responsible for both of the accounts. Once that other developer was involved with review manipulation, my account was closed.
I"m happy that I was able to clear things up with Apple and that Dash will soon come back to the App Store.
明擺著還是認為自己沒有錯,換做 Apple 來看的話會樂意么?說好的 Deal 是為了幫你恢復賬號同時申明 Apple 在這件事上沒做錯,但是作者還是沒有申明這一點。